Friday, March 24, 2006
While reading this wonderful post, I was reminded of something I read a couple of weeks ago. You might know about how comics treat rape and sexual abuse in a highly frivolous manner. Anything bad that happens to a woman is generally important only in how it affects the male (lead) character, and seldom in how it affects the woman herself. This, and many related things, are amply illustrated in the Women in Refrigerators syndrome.
And Garth Ennis is this Irish chap who writes comics that trounce religion (mostly Christianity) mercilessly. His comics usually assume that the key figures in Christianity exist, but they are always presented in a highly perverted (and sometimes original and interesting) manner. Ennis has written his fair share of women into refrigerators, and his treatment of gender issues is extremely heavy-handed and rather clueless. But I was struck by something he wrote in his run of Hellblazer* (which is a title I started reading because of this guy).
[ * Hellblazer is a comic book about John Constantine, a chain-smoking semi-alcoholic British guy who does magic stuff, and who was, for some reason, morphed into the all-American expressionless Keanu Reeves when they made a movie of it. The character was created by Alan Moore. ]
Garth Ennis, in Hellblazer, postulated that Jesus Christ was born from the angel Gabriel’s rape of Mary, which Gabriel had committed on God’s orders. And now (in the twentieth century), Gabriel is hating God, and is going to fall, and one of the reasons he resents God is for making him do that.
Now consider that this is a god who can do such a thing to one of his own beloved creations. What kind of god might he be?
Ennis, in his story, was more concerned with Gabriel, but this is the part that struck me the most. And which is why, in spite of Ennis’s fetish for guns and for thrusting war stories into almost every title he writes, I will continue to read his books.
And since we are on the topic, I will take this opportunity to point you to this excellent quote.
Current music: Those Crimson Tears – Ed Harcourt
And Garth Ennis is this Irish chap who writes comics that trounce religion (mostly Christianity) mercilessly. His comics usually assume that the key figures in Christianity exist, but they are always presented in a highly perverted (and sometimes original and interesting) manner. Ennis has written his fair share of women into refrigerators, and his treatment of gender issues is extremely heavy-handed and rather clueless. But I was struck by something he wrote in his run of Hellblazer* (which is a title I started reading because of this guy).
[ * Hellblazer is a comic book about John Constantine, a chain-smoking semi-alcoholic British guy who does magic stuff, and who was, for some reason, morphed into the all-American expressionless Keanu Reeves when they made a movie of it. The character was created by Alan Moore. ]
Garth Ennis, in Hellblazer, postulated that Jesus Christ was born from the angel Gabriel’s rape of Mary, which Gabriel had committed on God’s orders. And now (in the twentieth century), Gabriel is hating God, and is going to fall, and one of the reasons he resents God is for making him do that.
Now consider that this is a god who can do such a thing to one of his own beloved creations. What kind of god might he be?
Ennis, in his story, was more concerned with Gabriel, but this is the part that struck me the most. And which is why, in spite of Ennis’s fetish for guns and for thrusting war stories into almost every title he writes, I will continue to read his books.
And since we are on the topic, I will take this opportunity to point you to this excellent quote.
Current music: Those Crimson Tears – Ed Harcourt
March 24, 2006 3:38 pm
There are many notable exceptions to the rape being made frivolous in comics rule, though. Especially these days. One notable instance that pops into my head is the sexual assault of one superheroine by a superhero in Watchmen (won't give it away for anyone who hasnt read). It sure did resonate in the woman's life.
March 26, 2006 7:33 am
Of course, there are exceptions. And now that many writers are starting to acknowledge the problem, I hope the exceptions will become the rule. But even the example you give is slightly problematic - the events that transpire later can be read (and have been read by some) as 'women really want it' - although they certainly shouldn't be read that way. This example would've functioned better if the rest of Alan Moore's writing didn't treat assault (not just sexual) like it sometimes does (Miracleman, The Killing Joke are examples that spring to mind). But Moore's certainly better than most.
March 27, 2006 11:13 pm
good point.....and mostly very true. I read some post or site (by one of the few women comic artists) who pointed out exactly the same. It's used as an excuse for the hero to have a motive for revenge/hunting down an arch-enemy (hindi-film ishtyle, where villain rapes/kills girlfriend/sister).
But Allan Moore's comics are really fantastic....
March 28, 2006 10:10 am
What kind of God? A very Old-Testamenty God, it seems to me. And it's a little funny that it takes Gabriel all that time to start hating his boss...
By the idea, I was formerly at http://heyjune.blogspot.com - it's defunct now, pretty much.
March 28, 2006 12:36 pm
@Sunil: Yes, more and more people on the net are pointing this out, and making it clear to writers not only that it is offensive, but also that readers realise it is simply a way of falling back on cliches to get out of creative thinking.
One of my regular reads, When Fangirls Attack, has links to many other such posts if you're interested.
Alan Moore's fabulous, of course. :)
@Hamlet Pow Pow Pow (which, BTW, is an extremely cool handle): Yep, this is a very 'My will be done' sort of guy.
And it's a little funny that it takes Gabriel all that time to start hating his boss...
The angels in DC comics mythology are not supposed to have free will. They have been (or so it seems) created for the express purpose of bringing to fruition the word of the Lord. Which is why Lucifer, in spite of being callous and manipulative, is a hero figure - he rebelled, and he has also come to the conclusion that, even if his fall might have been planned by God, he has to try to do the best he can.
God (at least in DC's Vertigo mature readers line) generally comes across as a masturbatory and self-important prick.
March 12, 2007 7:29 pm
I have a funny adult joke site/blog. It pretty much covers ##KEYWORD## related stuff.