Saturday, August 19, 2006
There was a time when Jethro Tull was a highly respected band. They had a distinctive folksy-bluesy sound, they were generally well-loved, and their frontman Ian Anderson had created a delightful image for himself – that of a one-legged minstrel expertly playing the flute.
But by and by, Anderson turned more progressive, and, after their first two prog-rock albums – Aqualung and Thick as a Brick – ever more self-indulgent, and the band (with only two core members left – Anderson and guitarist Martin Barre) descended into bad synth-laden heavy metal. They also, along the way, lost their popularity and acclaim, and, like many prog-rock bands, collected around themselves a dedicated and rabid bunch of fanatics, thus preventing them from realising how bad they had become.
But in the last few years, Ian Anderson seems to have come to his senses, and (like some other dinosaurs I could mention) realised the importance of creating songs rather than ruminations set to soundtracks.
His last few albums – be they Tull or solo albums – have had melodies rather empty flute-blowing, and music rather than mindless heavy-metal guitar. And the best of this lot is his latest solo album – the 2003 release Rupi’s Dance.
Rupi’s Dance is an album by Ian Anderson containing simple songs about simple things, but it manages not to be simplistic. The songs are on subjects ranging from watching animals – in zoos or elsewhere – to simply watching life going by. The topics of the songs can be guessed from their titles – ‘A Raft of Penguins’, ‘Old Black Cat’, ‘Lost in Crowds’, and so on. Ian never goes off the point, and the point is never laboured. Rupi’s Dance is, like the best Tull albums, charming, slightly sad, with Ian’s love for humankind tinged with his trademark derision for all of us.
But Rupi’s Dance is an old man’s album, and Ian seems to have tired of hating other people. The lyrics (available here, with commentary) seem appreciative and surprisingly gentle, and rather than ridiculing people, he is mocking people’s traits and characteristics, and never too harshly. The music is similar in style, if not in quality, to old classics like ‘Living in the Past’ and ‘Life Is a Long Song’, and is notable for the absence of the heavy and irritating tone of Barre Guitar (I think Barre’s a truly underrated guitarist, but I hate the guitar tone he picked up in the 80s). Even the lesser songs are a pleasant listen.
In fact, Rupi’s Dance is Ian at his most seductive and welcoming since 1978’s Heavy Horses, and at his most tender and personal since perhaps 1969’s Stand Up. And it actually manages to fare well (albeit not exceedingly so) in comparison with these two classics.
Anyone who likes early Tull, or simply folksy music in general, should get this album. It’s not a work of genius, it’s not even consistently good, but it is a pleasant surprise nonetheless.
But by and by, Anderson turned more progressive, and, after their first two prog-rock albums – Aqualung and Thick as a Brick – ever more self-indulgent, and the band (with only two core members left – Anderson and guitarist Martin Barre) descended into bad synth-laden heavy metal. They also, along the way, lost their popularity and acclaim, and, like many prog-rock bands, collected around themselves a dedicated and rabid bunch of fanatics, thus preventing them from realising how bad they had become.
But in the last few years, Ian Anderson seems to have come to his senses, and (like some other dinosaurs I could mention) realised the importance of creating songs rather than ruminations set to soundtracks.
His last few albums – be they Tull or solo albums – have had melodies rather empty flute-blowing, and music rather than mindless heavy-metal guitar. And the best of this lot is his latest solo album – the 2003 release Rupi’s Dance.
Rupi’s Dance is an album by Ian Anderson containing simple songs about simple things, but it manages not to be simplistic. The songs are on subjects ranging from watching animals – in zoos or elsewhere – to simply watching life going by. The topics of the songs can be guessed from their titles – ‘A Raft of Penguins’, ‘Old Black Cat’, ‘Lost in Crowds’, and so on. Ian never goes off the point, and the point is never laboured. Rupi’s Dance is, like the best Tull albums, charming, slightly sad, with Ian’s love for humankind tinged with his trademark derision for all of us.
But Rupi’s Dance is an old man’s album, and Ian seems to have tired of hating other people. The lyrics (available here, with commentary) seem appreciative and surprisingly gentle, and rather than ridiculing people, he is mocking people’s traits and characteristics, and never too harshly. The music is similar in style, if not in quality, to old classics like ‘Living in the Past’ and ‘Life Is a Long Song’, and is notable for the absence of the heavy and irritating tone of Barre Guitar (I think Barre’s a truly underrated guitarist, but I hate the guitar tone he picked up in the 80s). Even the lesser songs are a pleasant listen.
In fact, Rupi’s Dance is Ian at his most seductive and welcoming since 1978’s Heavy Horses, and at his most tender and personal since perhaps 1969’s Stand Up. And it actually manages to fare well (albeit not exceedingly so) in comparison with these two classics.
Anyone who likes early Tull, or simply folksy music in general, should get this album. It’s not a work of genius, it’s not even consistently good, but it is a pleasant surprise nonetheless.
August 21, 2006 9:10 am
If it's even half as good as Heavy Horses, I will give it a spin.
I agree about their synth experiments, but will disagree with you about Barre's tone, especially in their 80s albums (I suppose you are referring to Crest of a Knave?)
Martin Barre did add tons of crunch to his sound, which, IMO, made Tull's music dramatic.
August 21, 2006 11:53 am
It's definitely at least half as good as Heavy Horses, so go ahead. :)
My stance on Barre's guitar is based on my personal preference. I don't mind the tone itself, I mind how it permeates through the entirety of these albums (Crest of a Knave, Rock Island), and seems to be an attempt at masking the lack of creativity. The 'drama' comment is interesting, because it generally seems to me that, in these albums, they're very excited about something I can't actually see.
I will readily admit that Rupi's Dance is also generally (although not entirely) constructed around one tone of one instrument - Ian's flute. But I like that tone, and don't mind the abundance of it, mainly because the album doesn't lack in melodies.
August 21, 2006 1:38 pm
My stance on Barre's guitar is based on my personal preference.
But of course. Why else would we be talking about it :)
(Funnily enough, Tull's flute is the one thing I am *not* crazy about. Anderson's not a virtuoso player nor is he always an expressive player. What he can do is channel Brit-folk/blues very well.)
If Napster has this album up, I will check it out.
August 22, 2006 4:51 am
me, i have never heard much tull, so ive no idea about 'em. i did like this write up though. as we elegantly used to say in college... "shtyle"! :D
August 22, 2006 1:11 pm
@km:
But of course. Why else would we be talking about it :)
Very true. :)
My affection for Ian's flute (er ... no pun intended) comes from the way he makes the flute sound an essential part of the song rather than a tacked-on embellishment (which probably contributes to the fact that, at least in the early albums, not every song had a flute part). But I agree with you - his playing is most effective on folksy-bluesy songs.
@m:
Fankoo. :)
If you do want to check out Tull, I'd say the best albums are Stand Up and Thick as a Brick, and the quintessential albums are probably Aqualung, the singles compilation Living in the Past, and perhaps Heavy Horses.
August 30, 2006 10:57 am
"The Tull man! The Tull!"
hehe
September 04, 2006 1:24 pm
Long live TULL :d \m/
September 06, 2006 7:11 am
I like the flutey JT stuff! And I've not heard 'Rupi's Dance' yet, I should like to.